However, magnetic ballasts are voltage, wattage and bulb typespecific. Electronic vs magnetic ballasts in order to run a high intensity discharge bulb hid, you will need a ballast. The majority of ballasts sold today are energyefficient magnetic types. A major efficiency improvement of hp ballasts, electronic or magnetic, is in the reduced. Magnetic vs electronic ballast, pros and cons please page 2. Ee 5741 design of electronic ballasts eric persson exec. These ballasts are smaller and lighter than magnetic versions. Look at the wiring diagram on the ballast label to make sure. A lamp ballast system consisting of a magnetic ballast and two 32w t8 lamps requires approximately 70 w. Pdf there is a common misconception that energy saving is always equivalent to. A single electronic ballast can operate up to four lamps, where magnetic ballasts can only support two. May 01, 2015 not a huge one, but there is a difference in favor of the digital ballast. Magnetic ballasts work at a frequency of around 60 hz, whereas electronic ballasts work at an increased frequency of around 20,000 hz. Life cycle assessment of magnetic and electronic ballast for.
Magnetic ballasts are operated in 5060hz line frequency. Our goal here is to highlight the major differences between the ballast types which are either magnetic or electro. However, direct dropin led tubes are compatible only with fixtures that have electronic ballasts. And there are two types of ballasts in each family. Electronic ballasts alter the flow of electricity in the light bulb by using a series of induction coils that are separated from one another. They can take all kinds of abuse both physical and electrical without failing. The difference between an electronic ballast and a. Depending on your lighting layout, this may reduce the costs of an upgrade, since you may not have to do a oneforone replacement of your old ballasts. Electronic ballasts are often designed around their magnetic ballast predecessors. Magnetic ballast and electronic ballast on the same circuit. Magnetic ballasts are made of wire coiled so as to create a. Magnetic ballasts are just about bullet proof, being made mostly of copper windings. Articles glossary case studies standards watch downloads internet. The boost pfc circuit is controlled by the vs and pfc pins of the ic.
This is why fluorescent lamps using electronic ballasts do. Electronic ballasts change the frequency of the current without any change in the voltage. Ballasts include weldedon brackets for easy replacement mounting. If so, they would be electronic, if not then they are magnetic. Applications notes due to differences in wiring architecture between magnetic and electronic ballast systems, multiple magnetic ballast systems will require a complete replacement of all ballasts and wiring. Doest help because you cant see it hear it but magnetic ballasts make a noise when starting. A full range of high quality electronic and magnetic ballasts regardless of control method. For this reason they feed less power into the lamp than a magnetic ballast does. Ballast compatible, plug and play, or direct dropin led tubes make upgrading to costsaving, longlife led technology easy. Mar 15, 2012 a single electronic ballast can operate up to four lamps, where magnetic ballasts can only support two. Page 1 of 3 magnetic vs electronic ballast, pros and cons please posted in lighting and ventilation. Fluorescent lamps require ballasts to provide the starting voltage and limit the electrical current during lamp operation.
Universal is the leader in energy saving electronic ballasts. Electronic ballast for high pressure sodium lamp has reached a matured. Magnetic ballasts are coreandcoil electromagnetic ballasts. Hps lamps offer distinguished lighting performance compared to other alternatives. The complete guide to ballasts for fluorescent lights. I bought a magnetic watt hps setup back in the day, plugged it in, and the fucker caught fire on the second day. Romanian balast electronic philips hfs 2x18w uout 380v warm start. Its been my experience that the magnetic core and coil ballasts are at a much higher risk of catching fire. Some basic facts and some advanced information on ballasts. These use a magnetic output transformer, an emi filter, a rectifier and integrated circuitry to manage the flow of current very precisely.
Magnetic vs electronic ballast, pros and cons please. While magnetic ballasts are simple and easy in their design and operating principle, the more sophisticated electronic ballast just has too many advantages. Electronic ballasts lighting research center rensselaer. When replacing a magnetic ballast with an electronic ballast the black and white power wires are connected the same as before, and the ground as well. The circuit includes figure 6 the control for both the boost pfc and the halfbridge resonant stages. With enhanced capabilities to downsize the luminaire housings and reduce wiring costs, vs electronic hid ballasts lead the way to electronic solutions for hid lighting. Company confidential typical design procedure for ballast 12. It does this through the principle of electrical gas discharge. This is a product label and images for an advance ballast, model vs 2s601tp, rapid start electronic ballast, 277 volts, 60 hertz. An electronic ballast can be smaller and lighter than a comparablyrated magnetic one.
Looking online, it seems that there are two different types of ballasts. I wired them using the pattern of the magnetic ballasts i took out, 2 ballast blue to blue and ballast red to red on one end, ballast black to black and power and ballast white to white and common white on the other end not the diagram on the ballasts ballast blue. What is the ballast wiring set up when converting from a t12. Sep 15, 2012 i replaced t12 magnetic ballast with t12 electronic ballast. May 04, 20 how to install a t8 electronic fluorescent ballast in an old magnetic t12 ballast fixture duration. I replaced magnetic ballasts with electronic ballasts in a. Magnetic ballasts usually have greater power losses than electronic ballasts. Can you replace a magnetic ballast with an electronic. The electronic ballast according to the invention has a reduced number of magnetic components resulting in a reduction in size and cost of the electronic ballast.
However, electronic ballasts are several times more expensive than the plain passive magnetic models and much more susceptible to certain disturbances and are likely to become themselves a source of disturbances. An electrical ballast is a device placed in series with a load to limit the amount of current in an electrical circuit a familiar and widely used example is the inductive ballast used in fluorescent lamps to limit the current through the tube, which would otherwise rise to a destructive level due to the negative differential resistance of the tubes voltagecurrent characteristic. Magnetic ballasts are made of wire coiled so as to create a magnetic field while electronic ballasts use. As the new wave of energy saving appliances gripped the world, technology made the fluorescent lamps shrink in thickness as well as reduced. Digital ballasts, on the other hand, are a newer technology, instead use electronic circuitry to regulate the amount of charge given, bringing more efficiency with. Magnetic ballasts are the older ballast technology. A wiring diagram typically provides info regarding the relative position and. Optimal selection and operation of ballasts for fluorescent lamps. Difference between electronic ballast and inductive ballast. There are two types of ballasts utilized in lighting fixtures, the electronic and the magnetic ballast. Comparison of dimmable electromagnetic and electronic ballast. Three advantages electronic ballast compare to magnetic. Hi stoners, please forgive the newbie question, but am about to buy a light and would like to ask if someone can explain the pros and cons of digital.
There are two types of ballasts commonly available for residential lighting. Page 2 of 3 magnetic vs electronic ballast, pros and cons please posted in lighting and ventilation. To make upgrading to an electronic ballast as easy as possible, keystone offers two solutions. Electronic ballast vs magnetic ballast in terms of. Economic study of replacing conventional ballast with electronic. Comparison of dimmable electromagnetic and electronic ballast systemsan assessment on energy efficiency and lifetime. An electronic ballast uses solid state electronic circuitry to provide the proper starting and operating electrical conditions to power discharge lamps. High frequency electronic ballast provides line frequency. This helps to regulate the initial electricity current given. However, compared to a magnetic bal last, its weight is substantially. A quick way to tell which ballast electronic or magnetic.
And our ultim8 and accustart ballasts feature high efficiency designs and programmed start technology that dramatically enhances lamp life. Certainly not enough to be concerned about and also due to the mounting positions in the beds are not in a close enough proximity to the tanner to be of any. An electronic ballast or electrical ballast is a device which controls the starting voltage and the operating currents of lighting devices. What is the difference between an electronic and a magnetic. Electronic and magnetic ballasts helvar luminaire components. People have grown up with the sights and sounds of fluorescent lamps buzzing to life after a few attempts. That is when the fluorescent lamp reached the same light output, electronic ballast can transfer low output power to fluorescent lamp. Simple control circuits for electronic ballast design. Replacing a light fixture magnetic ballast with an electronic ballast. The wiring to the lamp sockets must be converted as shown on the wiring diagram on the new electronic ballast. Harmonic interference of electronic ballast might disrupt the it, communication and sensitive electronic device eg in medical operation room 4. Electronic ballasts use circuits to control the flow of current. Check the ballast label against the labels on the lamps to make sure that. Manufactured by advance transformer company, incorporated, 2950 north, western avenue, chicago, illinois in 1967.
Both types of ballast stabilize the raw electricity into a consistent lighting source, they just go about it in a different way. Difference between electronic ballast and magnetic ballast. There are two lamp families that work with a ballast. Electronic ballast vs magnetic ballast in terms of electrical. For the fluorescent family, both t12 linear fluorescents and twopin cfls use magnetic ballasts. I replaced magnetic ballasts with electronic ballasts in a pair of parallelwired two bulb f96t12 fixtures in my brothers shop. A wiring diagram is a streamlined standard pictorial representation of an electric circuit. Electronic ballast installed at the site without a constant power supply, will shorthen life of the ballast itself. Schematic of the central dimming system for magneticballastdriven lighting system. This is why fluorescent lamps using electronic ballasts do not flicker or emit any buzzing sounds. This life of magnetic ballast will help reduce maintenance cost. An electronic ballast is usually quieter than a magnetic one, which produces a. Electronic ballasts are made of circuit boards, relays, capacitors and transistors. They are cheaper to produce and more durable than electronic ballasts.
Instant start electronic fluorescent replacement ballast. I recently replaced my kitchen ballast, and the new one was much lighter than the old one. Mar 15, 2020 an electronic ballast or electrical ballast is a device which controls the starting voltage and the operating currents of lighting devices. Magnetic ballasts operate lamps at line frequency 60 hertz hz in north america and are usually the least expensive. Universal c2642unvme compact fluorescent ballast, 2 lamp, 26w cfl, 120277v. Jan 03, 2011 i replaced magnetic ballasts with electronic ballasts in a pair of parallelwired two bulb f96t12 fixtures in my brothers shop. Screw the electronic ballast into the fixture, in the same place where the magnetic one was. All units 175 watts and above are multivolt capable. Philips advance ambistar 40watt 2lamp t12 rapid start high frequency electronic replacement ballast. Imo unless you want a dimmable ballast magnetic is a much better value in the long run. Electronic sign ballasts have many advantages over magnetic ballasts in addition to their energy savings. Electronic hid designed to provide optimal lamp performance and maximum energy savings.
Jan 29, 2014 page 2 of 3 magnetic vs electronic ballast, pros and cons please posted in lighting and ventilation. From the reading i have done there still can be slight rf interference even with the sheilding. They also change the frequency of the electrical current without changing the voltage. Manufactured by advance transformer company, incorporated, 2950 north, western avenue, chicago, illinois in 1987. Electronic ballast magnetic ballast universal lighting technologies is a subsidiary of panasonic lighting americas, a member of the panasonic corporation eco solutions company 2lamp rapid start to 2lamp electronic instant start retrofit wiring diagrams notes. A complete light system is made of three main components. Comparison of magnetic ballast and electronic ballast.
This is applicable for 2lamp t12 rapid start to a 2lamp electronic t8 system. Hi stoners, please forgive the newbie question, but am about to buy a light and would like to ask if someone can explain the pros and cons of digital vs magnetic ballasts please. Philips advance optanium 2530watt 2 or 3lamp t8 4 ft. Pdf in this paper, several high power lighting networks based on high. They contain a magnetic core of several laminated steel plates wrapped with copper windings. Thats a lot of money for a ballast i think it is electronic, you would think you could use any modern electronic ballast to do the job.
An electrical ballast is a device placed in series with a load to limit the amount of current in an. A lampballast system consisting of a magnetic ballast and two 32w t8 lamps. Trying to decide between an electronic or magnetic ballast. For the use phase, magnetic ballast used more energy 5 kwh than electronic ballast 45 kwh and also registered more impact during the use phase with 3. However, replacing magnetic ballasts with electronic ballasts is not without its complications. Discussion in growing marijuana indoors started by minigrower, feb 9. May 18, 20 magnetic ballast, when they go bad, can be fixed or rebuilt pretty quickly at a relatively low cost. It shows the components of the circuit as streamlined shapes, as well as the power and also signal connections between the gadgets.
An electronic ballast will convert power frequency to a very high frequency to initialize the gas discharge process in fluorescent lamps. Connect the power and neutral wires to the corresponding ballast wires. A quick video i took with the slow motion mode on my phone. These consist of a large transformer, a capacitor and a starter contained in a single case. Jan 29, 2014 page 1 of 3 magnetic vs electronic ballast, pros and cons please posted in lighting and ventilation. I assume that is because the new ballast is electronic and the old one was magnetic.
While magnetic ballasts in fluorescent lamps work at a frequency of 60hz, electronic ballasts greatly increase that. If you have the money for an extra ballast or two i say go digital. This is a product label and images for an advance ballast, model vs110tp, rapid start electronic ballast 120 volts, 60 hertz. Every half line cycle, they reignite the lamp and limit the lamp current. Compared with electromagnetic ballasts, electronic ballasts have a much shorter lifetime and are not recyclable. The ballast in my bathroom burned out brand new bulb wont light up. A magnetic ballast has a core made out of steel plates wrapped in a copper wire coil creating a magnetic field. The inductor ballast represent the conventional ballasting approaches, and is known as magnetic ballasts. Lighting solutions product reference 3 lighting solutions for a sustainable future as concerns about energy utilization and its effect on global climate change continue to make headlines, everyone is looking for ways to costeffectively reduce their.
1183 926 1262 1102 35 1582 1250 580 929 793 1456 985 1134 208 726 664 1153 250 1624 101 548 1415 524 1070 887 324 882 1127 791 492 194 112 868